Log In to add custom notes to this or any other game. By John Clements. No sorry a katana actually is a very good weapon vs undead at least if its a real katana and not some shit made sword by some dude in china in a factory. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Its got long reach with a nice point, double edged blade, and a nice thick heavy cross guard and pommel. All motions are cruelly effecient and all the power comes from the core of your body. A famous blacksmith is testing a katana vs a german longsword. ATI isn’t ignoring the non-graphics market, either. Without throwing in the human interaction, you have two bits of metal laying on the floor. If they are both talented with their swords, it's fairly neutral. 1; 2; 3 Page 3 of 4; 4; Loweeeee. it was analogous to modern soldiers having a Pistol in addition to having an assault rifle. I don't know why, I prefer swift stikes versus brutish swings, but whatever. Case Study – Katana VS Longsword. Claymore. We opened with a comparison of the highland claymore versus the katana. He made both weapons exactly in the same way like they were made in the past. The claymore weight was usually around 2.5 kg (5.5 lbs), and the Katana was often around 1.2 kg (2.65 lbs). Claymore is a coordinate term of sword. A katana is for harassing peasants, it's not a weapon used for combat between armoured warriors, like the claymore is. Zweihänder It is their battle to lose. BudK is offering forged katanas from $40 right now. I feel like that analogy is a bit harsh, I mean, they are both designed for combat and arguably both suited for a 1v1. If you were practicing JSA a katana would be a no brainer. The Scottish Highland claymore is a two-handed sword with a cross hilt, is about 55-inches long and weighs about 5.5lbs. Aggressive clock gating is used throughout the chip, which allows a card with the performance of the 4850 to get by with just a single PCI Express power connector. ... Last resort give me a box of grenades or claymore mines. It's already a light blade, you are hurting the structure when you do that. Basically, neither weapon was very good for one-on-one fighting. If you were a Scottish reenactor so would a claymore. There are several katana styles, and without knowing which style, what skill the user has, what type of strength and agility they have, as well as the same for the claymore, you cant really say. And when you pump up AA, performance doesn’t fall off a cliff. Equally skilled doesn't mean it's down to the sword; a claymore takes a fair bit more heft to swing then a katana does, so if they are equally crap, then the katana guy wins. It wasn't a bludgeoning tool, many of the claymore blades are flat in cross section, making them good for cutting and relatively light for their length of 107 cm (42 in), versus the katana's 60 cm (23.5 in). While both swords certainly require skill and training to use well, the claymore’s advantage lie in power and reach, while the katana’s strengths lie in speed and precision. Dat 1h R2 Kreygasm. Its very sharp so it won’t get stuck in them as easily and its not quite as heavy as a european sword. Longsword and Katana Considered. I think it's a subjective sort of question that only you can answer. In the Long Sword vs Katana debate, have they ever tried forging both out of the same materials? If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. This site may earn affiliate commissions from the links on this page. Not too heavy with a long reach and fairly quick attack. My first character's weapon was a Dragon Claymore. The katana, on the other hand, was made for these encounters, able to slash quickly in between the opponent's attacks to inflict great damage against unarmored opponents. Katana break.
They are made for you on order. I am an amateur sword fighter who knows a bit about both weapons and have trained with both. It returned to this position for Fifth Edition, as the katana has the highest Accuracy (the limit for attack roll successes) of all core melee weapons. Like the Dark Katana, it can only be found at Obsidian Pinnacle, but on any difficulty. The claymore is actually meant to be an anti cavalry weapon. Yes the katana users are trained to block with the dull edge of they can immediately counter attack with the sharp side, with a double edge I find its easier to block then go into a counter attack and it has more options and ways to do so then the katana. We’ll get to those shortly. Katana is more brittle in general, but that's not going to matter in a fight like this. So the claymore was twice as heavy, but it was also balanced about 6 inches from the hilt, just like a katana. They are going to be aware that getting you to overextend yourself is the only hope of victory. It all comes down though to knowing your weapon and training with it. Of course, Nvidia will talk up the other capabilities of the 280 GTX, including CUDA and PhysX. On foot, he is slow at best, and clumsy at worst. As for drawing on the attack. ATI: We’ve got DirectX 10.1. The Heartstealer is a unique variant of the claymore, a large sword that swings slowly but deals a wallop of a hit. If you have actual warriors fighting with actual equipment, the claymore stomps. Katana. Nvidia has greater resources, but ATI has proven itself nimble and focused. Only if they are both unarmored. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6LcGEzUmdM. Great swords are also plenty fast when properly held. It can and can do so very well also. with that, i disagree. We strongly encourage you to read our updated PRIVACY POLICY and COOKIE POLICY. The claymore was a battlefield weapon, the Katana was more for personal defense in close quarters or if a primary weapon was broken. Katana is more of a dexterity based weapon whereas claymores are pretty strength based. There is no real scenario in which you can say one blade is 'better' than another because they were made for two different things, and the styles are completely different. It can't parry the claymore very well, but that rarely occurs in kendo anyway. On the one hand, we have Nvidia’s new GeForce 280 GTX. As much as I love the scottish claymore, the katana wielder would probably win in this case. Stick one on a man on a horse, watch him lay about him tearing people in half with the power of his strikes. The Scottish name "claymore" (Scottish Gaelic: claidheamh mór, lit. Based on our initial benchmark testing, ATI delivered in spades. Vs Broadsword i did this before but i was a noob and didn't do any pictures or anything an it just wasn't a good thread. The claymore in no way is a cavalry weapon. Overall the katana should prevail. so if they are both meh katana 7/10. That is, it’s too long to wear, and too big to use in one hand with any reasonable expectation of ease. 41; Jul 2nd 2016, 6:28am. [ example 1] (http://imgur.com/QyQkmPO) [ example 2] (http://imgur.com/jiLQVx6) The claymore was made to deal with both heavily European armored targets and unarmored targets. I am going to just say that all combatants are decent with their weapon. Turns out a thingy of chainmail stops a katana pretty fucking good. Rather than throw massive transistor counts at the problem, they were given specific cost and die size targets—in addition to a fairly aggressive minimum power envelope. I feel like a lot of people here are laboring under the impression that katanas are feather light and claymores axe heavy. This was a tactic used by people with a Claymore in the middle ages. This newsletter may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. With him being lighter on his feet than the Scotsman, the kendo practitioner should find it easy to just dodge the blows. A gamer who pays $200 for a video card is unlikely to spend over $1,000 for a monitor. Also the claymore was longer and had more reach, so it could strike at the katana wielder first and having to block that first blow as they come in to range to attack can put the katana at a disadvantage. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6LcGEzUmdM explains the point better than I could. When swung, the Phoenix Edge shoots a small burst of flame in the direction the player is aiming, which can kill additional enemies and detonate oil barrels. Subscribing to a newsletter indicates your consent to our, ET Deals: Nearly $800 Off Dell 2020 Vostro 15 7500 Core i7, Ring Video Doorbell 3 w/ Echo Show 5 for $149, Gaming Laptop With Ryzen 7 5800H, Mobile RTX 3080 Leaked, Astronomers Spot Potentially Artificial Radio Signal From Nearby Star, This End Of Year Flash Sale From Skullcandy Offers Up Headphones For Up To 56 Percent Off, DOSBox Pure Launches to Make Classic Games Easier to Play. Its advantage of shearing through armor is virtually negated in the unarmored scenario which means it's packing a whole lot of useless weight. If you take out factors like individual soldier skill, armor and various other variables then my vote would be with the broadsword since that includes the claymore. With this sword even if attacked by a heavily armored opponent you can turn it around and use it to bludgeon them with it or use it as a giant crow bar to try and rip their armor off. if they're both shit then the person with the claymore won't be able to use his extra reach on the weapon to any real effect and the katana imo would be much easier to just pick up and use since it doesn't weigh a fuck ton. This means that with it you can easily go from a block right in to a counter attack with out having to bring the weapon around. it would be a little faster but a claymore also would have quite a bit more reach on it. The claymore user can play keep-away using long arcing strokes, but that is a dangerous game and won't work all the time. The two-handed grip and weight on a claymore necessitates a certain stance that is begging for a slice to the upper arms and elbows. He has better balance on the horse, better control over his power on the horse. If neither opponent has armour the slicing weapon will win, if they both have armour, even if it's just thin chainmail, the slicing weapon will be made less than worthless and the chopping weapon will be unhindered. Yes samurai had armor and the Katanas did have to find ways though it but its nothing like the heavy plate armor of Europeans. It depends on when you’re talking about, and the context of the conversation. Verdandi wrote: you forget that it is a magic torch. And this is basically a duel. The Phoenix edge has a slower swing speed and longer reach than the default katana, but not as much as Claymore Prototype. If its equal, then its a 5/10 chance, there will always be scenarios where the other can win hence why there's a 7/10 chances because you can recognize that its situational and theres a 3/10 the other will catch the other one out. Europeans have all sorts of different swords like the Zweihanders and Claymore, or the longswords like the Sub-type XVIIIb, Sub-type XVa, Spatha, Sub-type XVa, Oakeshott Type X Via, and more. The argument here is, the katana was a weapon of last resort (which would make sense; if it were a primary weapon, they'd be constantly trying to improve it somehow but it basically stayed the same for 700 years) and was used for chopping and slicing, rather than penetrating armor. [citation needed] The two handed claymore is an early Scottish version of a greatsword. The going idea in the comments was that Japanese folded steel is folded over so many times because of the impurities in japanese steel. Basically, neither weapon was very good for one-on-one fighting. And don’t forget, there’s a third weapon that will enter the fight in about eighteen months: Intel’s Larrabee. Nvidia may claim “better performance per shader core,” but ATI’s got efficiency where it counts—better performance per watt. And again this is a specific cutting motion that makes it even easier to break said katana. neither sword would really have any inherent advantage over the other imo it would all be up to the people using them. I think you're underestimating how effective a skilled archer can be, especially if they are not initially visible to each other. On the other hand, we have perpetual underdog AMD. For the first time in a long time, the choices between GPUs are starkly different. ATI: We’ve got hardware tessellation! 4th edition takes this trope in a weird direction, with the katana being better than the generic sword, as good as the mono-filament sword, but worse than the combat axe and claymore. A katana hits more lightly, then its curve makes it continue cutting as you draw the weapon from it's target, which makes for some very deep cuts on fleshy bits. Is it as fast as a GTX 280? It only appears lit to the user. If one is superior then that is how the fight sways, its the whole point of the question. It … The exclusive shop to buy custom made samurai swords, download our app for maximum convenient when building your custom Katana, Wakizashi, Tanto, Ninjato, Nodachi, Nagamaki. A Claymore by any other name.. by: Paul There is a fair amount of confusion surrounding the word 'Claymore' and technically it refers to two types of swords, the late medieval period two handed swords used in clan warfare and border clashes with the English (highlander) or the basket hilt one handed sword used by the Scottish military much longer than other armies (Scottish). Oct 17, 2018 @ 4:11am Katana can stun scrake if you attack from the rear as zerker, also fireaxe offperk (non-zerker) can stun scrake if you attack with alt (mmb) from behind too, both have their uses. That is not saying the katana cant block and quickly counter attack. You have two weapons, one for chopping and one for slicing. That is a style of katana use not often taught. And while Nvidia can currently claim leadership in Folding@home, the app has yet to be fully tweaked for the Radeon 4000 series. The problem here is that the claymore is a larger greatsword, and greatswords were never excellent to put on footmen anyway. AMD’s CPU guys have been doing a pretty good job of making lemonades out of lemons, including today’s launch of the 2GHz Phenom 9350, a 65W quad core CPU—a power envelope Intel’s 45nm quad-core Penryns have yet to match. The katana was a weapon of last resort because people would usually keep formation. Notify me about new: ... but I really loved the DeS Claymore. The claymore was a weapon used for cutting into dense pike formations then was used as a sort of spear once you closed with the enemy (which would also make sense, given that the scots extensively used pikes), or discarded in favor of another weapon. Press J to jump to the feed. See the claymore is the Swiss army knife of swords. both are being wielded by equally skilled opponents so its all down to the sword. It's a little faster than the claymore, whose weight is wasted against armorless people. Recently there was a gif of a Longsword breaking a katana and a katana bending when trying to do the same. Interestingly, both are two-handed swords. I will give it to the claymore 6.5 / 10. What it will really come down to over the long haul is how well each company executes on its vision. The 4850’s approach to power is also interesting. You're comparing apples and oranges. The two major competitors, Nvidia and AMD’s ATI division, have taken substantially different approaches to product design. Without a formation, the katana was depended on as a skirmishing weapon. if they're both equally skilled then it's a toss up since if katana dude get's inside claymore dudes guard it's done but if he can't then claymore dude wins. But it’s really not the same thing. Nvidia: We’ve got CUDA! Many schools actively disdain such principles of combat. As someone with some small experience with both, I wouldn't feel overly confident fighting against someone identical to me using either, but I think I'd give preference to the reach. Subscribe Today to get the latest ExtremeTech news delivered right to your inbox. Their latest GPU, the Radeon 4850, performs quite well, and is priced right, too, at under $200. PCMag Digital GroupExtremeTech is among the federally registered trademarks of Ziff Davis, LLC and may not be used by third parties without explicit permission. The Katana, as used by Japanese Samurai, is 38–40 inches long, and weighs less than two pounds. A katana would be significantly stiffer, and better up close than a claymore, but it would be very difficult to get within range of the sweeping cuts a claymore is capable of. Weighing in at 1.4 billion transistors and a gigabyte of video memory, the 280 GTX demonstrates what you can do when you throw massive transistor budget at the 3D graphics problem. Katana vs Straight Sword Dark Souls PlayStation 3 . © 1996-2020 Ziff Davis, LLC. Claymore or Scottish Basket Hilted Broadsword A common weapon among the clansmen during the Jacobite rebellions of the late 17th and early 18th centuries was the Scottish Basket Hilted Broadsword, commonly known as claidheamh mor or “claymores” – meaning “great sword” in Scottish Gaelic. The feature war goes back and forth, too. If we are talking about two master swordsmen then I would give it to the claymore about 6/10. I'm gonna attempt to get the Crescant right now. As nouns the difference between claymore and sword is that claymore is a large two-handed sword historically used by the scottish highlanders while sword is (weaponry) a long-bladed weapon having a handle and sometimes a hilt and designed to … Assuming no armor, katana, 6/10. It has a very long history of being a dueling weapon, and while The claymore was used in personal combat, i believe it paled compared to other weapons such as the rapier, Drik, or short sword. They are two of the world's most recognizable and iconic weapons in history: the European double-handed knightly sword and the feudal Japanese double-handed samurai sword. Course, both the claymore and the bastard sword are really low tier weapons in the first place, so you're kinda stuck choosing between two pieces of worthless junk lol Claymore is a great weapon. I understand, thats what this sub is about to a degree, but what you're asking is "What is better at carving a pumpkin, a ferrari or a rubber mallet?" In the hands of an unskilled user the chance of even on a successful strike you might break your sword on someone's arm bone and not necessarily remove the limbs utility. He even imported iron ore from japan for the katana to use the same material. What are the katana strengths and weaknesses against the European longsword? A greatsword is one word to describe a dedicated two-handed sword.

Even a large sword is 3 pounds. The name Claymore (claidheamh-mòr or "Great Sword") has been debated of its very origins as it was used to describe the Scottish basket-hilt sword and was later applied to the earlier two handed great swords which eventually became synonymous with all Scottish swords. I find generally the advantage goes to the person with reach. It comes out fast, it comes back fast, it hurts bad when it hits. Will Larrabee be a more advanced sword, or a different kind of weapon altogether? Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! I think an expert of their weapon at all styles would suffice for both weapons in this scenario. At their editor’s day event, they took pains to show off general purpose applications, right down to the same next-gen Photoshop demos and a video transcoding app (albeit different than the one Nvidia showed.) With two equally skilled opponents, i would give it to the claymore, if only because it has longer reach and has the ability to penetrate armor, and the katana has a circlejerk surrounding it that's largely just hype. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. At those resolutions, turning up AA is more useful than a few more frames per second—provided performance stays above that magical 60 fps number. Good price and performance is certainly important, but the ATI team’s approach to solving the problems was more interesting. Meant to be close in use to that of a pole arm rather than a traditional sword, more of a weapon you let someone impale themselves/horse around. You are indeed where you belong. Last the Claymore is double edged. I can think of several situations in which either would win, but in honest, its not the sword that wins the fight, its the fighter. "large/great sword") can refer to either the longsword with a distinctive two-handed grip, or the basket-hilted sword. They did an episode of deadliest warrior on this. The real question is "Claymore, or Katana + Fire Axe?" Likes Received 336 Posts 222. 100% agree. Ironically, neither weapon is especially good for defense, the claymore blade being somewhat flexible, and the katana having the opposite issue of being quite brittle. Also it's hard to tell, but it looks like someone put a fuller in the Katana for some reason? Sharp blades can easily cut through thick layers of cloth and leather. Officer. This may sound eerily similar to the marketing fight going on in CPUs between AMD and Intel. If you want to alter the fight conditions a bit, I'll give a new answer. all of our swords are fully functional and made of quality materials. So who’s going to win the war? The end result is a highly efficient GPU. Ironically, neither weapon is especially good for defense, the claymore blade being somewhat flexible, and the katana having the opposite issue of being quite brittle. Today, in the context of historical fencing, longsword means a wearable sword designed to be wielded in two hands. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Give them both plate mail and claymore wins 9/10. The katana is a quickdraw weapon, while the claymore is a bit more heavy. Listening to Scott Hartog, the chief architect for the Radeon 4000 series talk, it’s clear that they made a very conscious decision to approach the problem in a more elegant way. You realize right that the claymore was more used like a spear than to cleave things? Even at $200, it’s likely that there’s some price headroom, as the 4850 die size is considerably smaller than that of Nvidia’s 280 GTX. Both are capable weapons, in the hands of the right warrior. Each of these famous sword types owes its design to the marriage of pragmatic function with technological form. It’s more likely they’ll have a sub-$400, 22-inch display with 1680×1050. While Nvidia has dropped the price of the 9800 GTX to the $200 level, that card still requires two power connectors, and is a double-wide card. If this distance is much larger, the fight is more neutral, but I lean towards the katana. Loved that thing to death. Those differences between the two types of swords are pretty good metaphors for what’s happening in the GPU market today. The Scythe serves as a sidegrade to the Claymore: the Scythe is slightly stronger and cheaper than the Claymore but is a bit slower and has a slightly smaller range. Katana, Axe, and LAR of course #8. This would happen during the vast majority of these encounters, as a claymore is a rather unwieldy weapon at very close range no matter your physical strength. Nope, though it approaches the GTX 260 in some tests. I know few fighters who wouldn't make you work for every inch gained. And so it goes. If you make up a fantasy scenario where for some reason nobody has armour, sure it wins. The Heartstealer can deal as much as 2000 damage points an attack. Cavalry weapons tend to be thing you can set and do run by attacks. I’m sure both Nvidia and ATI wonder about that, too. A claymore hits like an axe, it just drives a wedge into the person. A claymore (/ ˈ k l eɪ m ɔːr /; from Scottish Gaelic: claidheamh-mòr, "great sword") is either the Scottish variant of the late medieval two-handed sword or the Scottish variant of the basket-hilted sword.The former is characterised as having a cross hilt of forward-sloping quillons with quatrefoil terminations and was in use from the 15th to 17th centuries. Zeke Boone. Also, there is proof that both can pierce a metal plate straight through. Nvidia: We’ve got PhysX! Well, in some cases, not bloody much. A katana would be significantly stiffer, and better up close than a claymore, but it would be very difficult to get within range of the sweeping cuts a claymore is capable of. The katana was not used on the battlefield so much ("samurai" as the west thinks of them used guns alot) but it was extensively used as a dueling weapon. However if both are meh, I would give it to the katana, the edge geometry makes it a very easy sword to cut with, while cutting correctly with a claymore requires quite a bit more skill. use our customization tool to create your battle ready Katana today. Samurai Sword instead of Claymore. Xbox 360 Nintendo Switch PC PlayStation 4 Xbox One. At the same time, the performance target was pretty aggressive, including substantial improvements in anti-aliasing performance. The secondary attack swings in such a wide arc that it hits anything within range across the entire Field of View, making the Scythe an excellent melee weapon to use for crowd control. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the whowouldwin community. Both swords are very effective weapons and would do serious damage. How far away do they start? If it was anywhere in the order of five feet or less, a skilled kendo iajutsu practitioner could kill the Scotsman with his unsheathe. The Scottish Highland claymore is a two-handed sword with a cross hilt, is about 55-inches long and weighs about 5.5lbs. But with its longer reach, and versatility to deal with all manner of enemies I give the edge to the Claymore. but its dead now so here is a better version! I stored my Daedric Katana in my house when I "found" (ahem murdered a guy and stole it from him ahem) a Daedric Claymore. To settle a debate between friends which sword would win in a 1 versus 1 situation. I don't know why this sub loves the concept of someone dancing around blows. i'm taking most of what i know from these videos: the claymore, and the katana. This last bit is pretty important.